Bold claim: Silent Night Deadly Night’s new entry is a wild ride that fans will either love for its festive chaos or roll their eyes at for its flaws. And this is the part most people miss: it tries to deliver modern sensibilities while still leaning hard into classic slasher shtick, which makes for a uniquely uneven but entertaining experience.
PLOT: A child witnesses his parents’ murder by a man in a Santa suit. Years later, as an adult, he dons a Santa costume himself and embarks on a violent quest for retribution against those responsible for the traumatic event from his childhood.
REVIEW: The Silent Night Deadly Night franchise has always been a shopping list of wild ideas—from a murderous “Garbage Day” moment to a killer toymaker and a witch coven—all stubbornly unrelated to each other. A remake stirred curiosity over a decade ago, so another sequel might have felt unnecessary. Yet Mike P. Nelson’s Silent Night Deadly Night reinvigorates the premise with a fresh tonal balance.
Like the original, the story follows Billy as he rampages in a Santa outfit. But the details have shifted to fit contemporary expectations. The film removes the rape subplot involving Billy’s mother and reduces the psychological heft of the backstory, yet it still delivers plenty of killer-Santa spectacle. It won’t satisfy viewers seeking depth or heavy meaning, but for those seeking a solid entertaining scare-thriller, it succeeds.
Casting helps a lot. I was curious to see Rohan Campbell take on Billy Chapman, and the performance leans toward a more approachable incarnation of the character. The new take makes Billy feel less irredeemable at first glance, with moments that delay villainy and add an air of complexity. Ruby Modine, familiar to many from Happy Death Day, brings emotional nuance and makes the dialogue land more naturally when she’s on screen. The romance between these two characters is a deliberate throughline that adds texture to the story.
There are twists and turns that will spark eye-rolls for some and genuine amusement for others. Some moments land embarrassingly on-the-nose and rely on exposition, yet they drift into the realm of “so bad it’s good” enough to stay palatable. Even the weaker moments feel aligned with the world rather than jarringly out of place, though the finale makes a bold swing that won’t land for everyone.
A recent trend involves heavy-handed title cards that spell out who’s getting killed. Silent Night Deadly Night leans into this device for nearly every kill, announcing the victim with a onscreen caption. It wears thin quickly and can feel condescending unless the visuals aren’t already conveying the point.
I carried some skepticism after seeing the Jason Voorhees-inspired short Sweet Revenge earlier this year, which missed the mark for me. But Nelson nails the Killer Santa concept this time around. The tone sits at a steady point between unsettling and entertaining, and the budget limitations are surprisingly non-disruptive to the immersion. The film keeps you engaged and immersed in its world throughout.
Labeling Silent Night Deadly Night a “great movie” in the traditional sense is tricky. It’s melodramatic, flashy, and occasionally goofy, yet it remains remarkably entertaining from start to finish. It’s destined to become part of a yearly Christmas rotation for those who crave festive mayhem alongside holiday cheer. It’s not as psychological or disturbing as the original, but it earns its place and its name. One wonders how many parents’ groups will react, and whether that controversy might fuel marketing in an age of polarizing discourse.
Silent Night Deadly Night hits theaters December 11, 2025.
7 out of 10
Subscribe to our weekly newsletter
Get the latest movie and TV news, first looks, reviews, and interviews, straight from the team to your inbox.
