Imagine a young rugby talent being labeled as a ‘luxury’ by a top-tier coach—not because they’re unnecessary, but because they’re so good they elevate the entire team. That’s exactly what’s happening with Phoenix Laulu-Togaga’e, whose move from Hull KR to Catalans Dragons has sparked excitement and debate in the rugby league world. But here’s where it gets controversial: Is letting go of such a player a strategic reshuffle or a missed opportunity for Hull KR? Let’s dive in.
As of January 31, 2026, Catalans Dragons’ head coach Joel Tomkins has been singing the praises of Laulu-Togaga’e, the 22-year-old playmaker who joined the squad after Hull KR’s recent overhaul. Tomkins didn’t hold back, calling the young star a ‘luxury’ addition—a term that’s both flattering and thought-provoking. After all, in a sport where every player counts, why would someone be considered a luxury? The answer lies in Laulu-Togaga’e’s versatility and raw talent. And this is the part most people miss: He’s not just a backup; he’s a game-changer who can seamlessly fill multiple positions, from one to seven, and even nine or outside-backs.
Laulu-Togaga’e’s journey to Perpignan wasn’t without its twists. Despite limited first-team appearances at Hull KR’s Sewell Group Craven Park and loan spells at Oldham, he’s now pushing for a starting spot in Tomkins’ matchday squad. His pre-season performance has been nothing short of impressive, earning him the number 14 shirt for his debut campaign with the Dragons. Tomkins, a former Hull KR player himself, admitted that reviewing Laulu-Togaga’e’s footage was a turning point. ‘He does a lot of good things,’ Tomkins told Hull Live, highlighting the player’s creativity, speed, and footwork. ‘He’s an exciting player—someone who does things you can’t really coach.’
But what makes Laulu-Togaga’e stand out isn’t just his skill; it’s his resilience. Despite his smaller frame, he’s tough, strong, and ready to take on any challenge. Tomkins has been transparent about his role, but the player’s determination has him knocking on the door of the starting 13. ‘I’ve got no qualms if Phoenix is in the team,’ Tomkins added. ‘We’ve got some serious quality with him.’
This move comes at a pivotal time for the Dragons, who are rebuilding after a rollercoaster 2025 season that saw them miss the playoffs. With 13 new signings and 15 departures, Tomkins is shaping a squad capable of competing at the highest level. Laulu-Togaga’e’s arrival is part of this transformation, and his impact is already being felt.
Here’s the bold question: Did Hull KR underestimate what they had in Laulu-Togaga’e, or was his departure a necessary step in their own squad reshuffle? While Hull KR focuses on defending their title with new signings, Catalans Dragons are reaping the rewards of their ‘luxury’ recruit. As the 2026 season kicks off, all eyes will be on Laulu-Togaga’e to see if he lives up to the hype—and whether Hull KR will come to regret letting him go.
What do you think? Is Phoenix Laulu-Togaga’e a luxury Hull KR could afford to lose, or a talent they should have fought to keep? Let us know in the comments below!
